Choice D is correct. It's given that , which can be rewritten as . Since the coefficient of the -term is positive, the graph of in the xy-plane opens upward and reaches its minimum value at its vertex. The x-coordinate of the vertex is the value of such that reaches its minimum. For an equation in the form , where , , and are constants, the x-coordinate of the vertex is . For the equation , , , and . It follows that the x-coordinate of the vertex is , or . Therefore, reaches its minimum when the value of is .
Alternate approach: The value of for the vertex of a parabola is the x-value of the midpoint between the two x-intercepts of the parabola. Since it’s given that , it follows that the two x-intercepts of the graph of in the xy-plane occur when and , or at the points and . The midpoint between two points, and , is . Therefore, the midpoint between and is , or . It follows that reaches its minimum when the value of is .
Choice A is incorrect. This is the y-coordinate of the y-intercept of the graph of in the xy-plane.
Choice B is incorrect. This is one of the x-coordinates of the x-intercepts of the graph of in the xy-plane.
Choice C is incorrect and may result from conceptual or calculation errors.